In Rowan County, a young man walks into the police station with his uncle and reports that his younger sister is missing. But there’s one detail that immediately raises red flags. No one has seen the girl for almost 2 years and during all that time, there wasn’t a single official missing person report. 13-year-old Erica Parsons had simply vanished from her family’s life quietly, without a search, without any explanation.
She had been adopted by her aunt and uncle, Casey Parsons and Sandy Parsons. And whenever Jamie started asking where his sister was, he was told she had moved to Asheville to live with her grandmother, a woman named Nan. It sounded believable until you actually start checking the story because according to Jamie, the reality inside that home was very different.
Erica had endured years of physical and emotional abuse. And even after her so-called disappearance, her parents kept collecting social benefits in her name as if she were still living right there with them. When investigators questioned Casey and Sandy, they denied everything. They called Jamie a liar, claiming he was making it all up because of a family conflict.
They insisted that back in 2011, Erica had gone to live with her biological grandmother. But even that version quickly started to fall apart. Their daughter Brooke said she had never gone anywhere with them. And at that point, the question became unavoidable. If everyone is lying, then who’s telling the truth? And more importantly, where is Erica? Things got even stranger when Casey claimed she had been in contact with this Nan through Facebook, but she couldn’t show a single message, no account, no contact information for the woman she
supposedly trusted with the child. And then investigators uncovered something even more disturbing. Erica’s biological grandmother had actually died back in 2005, long before Erica was ever said to have moved in with her. And in that moment, this story stopped feeling just strange and started to feel dangerous.
During the search efforts, about 2 weeks after Erica was officially reported missing, the street was blocked off. One of the neighbors told reporters, “One officer showed up at first and then before I even realized what was happening, there were probably 25, maybe 30 police cars out there. Officers canvassed the house multiple times, repeatedly checking the backyard of the family home, but despite all of that, they didn’t find anything significant.
Nothing that clearly pointed to what had happened. About a month after Jamie first reported Erica missing, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the FBI, joined the search, working alongside local law enforcement. The family home was searched again and again. Search warrants executed in August 2013 revealed that investigators removed dozens of items from the house.
Among them was a plastic bag filled with magazines about JonBenét Ramsey, along with a book about her case that contained handwritten notes, notes that strangely referenced home repairs. JonBenét Ramsey was a 6-year-old girl who was found murdered inside her own home on Christmas Day in 1996. Her case remains unsolved and still draws widespread public attention.
According to the search records, investigators also cut out and seized a section of drywall from inside a closet because of visible red stains. Baseboards from that same closet were removed and sent in for forensic testing. In addition to that, a pair of jeans with red stains was taken from the home.
A week later, new warrants were issued this time after investigators searched a storage unit that belonged to Sandy. From there, they seized parts of a vacuum cleaner, a videotape, school records, a hammer, and teeth. In those warrants, investigators referenced an earlier search stating that they had found no evidence that Erica Parsons was still living in the home or that her room or personal living space had been maintained there.
And at that point, investigators said the evidence was starting to tell a very clear story. Casey and Sandy knew one thing for certain, Erica was never coming back. Another key focus of the investigation centered on claims that Casey and Sandy continued receiving social benefits issued in Erica’s name even after she was no longer living with them.
Because of this, officials filed for a warrant to review and analyze their financial activity. In the affidavit submitted for that warrant, investigators stated, “It is believed that the ongoing desire to continue using funds, benefits, or financial assistance intended for the care of Erica Parsons or for her benefit led to a delay or even a complete failure to report Erica Parsons as missing in a timely manner.
” At that point, one thing was clear, the family kept receiving money for Erica even after she was gone. Working alongside the Federal Bureau of Investigation, investigators reviewed bank records and found consistent monthly payments more than $600 at a time. Money that was supposed to support a child who hadn’t been seen in years.
The defense pushed back, arguing that technically everything was legal. They were still her legal guardians. Erica was simply living with her grandmother. But here’s the thing, if everything was normal, then why didn’t anyone call the police? When Casey and Sandy began appearing in interviews, investigators noticed something subtle but almost impossible to fake.
They spoke about Erica in the past tense, like she was already gone. Meanwhile, her biological mother, Carolyn Parsons, spoke very differently. She’s my daughter. I still love her. As if Erica were still out there somewhere. Despite all of this, the couple kept insisting she had been seen, that someone had called, that there were signs she was alive.
But when they were directly asked why they never contacted police, there was no real answer. Instead, Sandy focused on something else. She said she just wanted Erica to call and she wanted her two younger children, who had already been removed from the home, returned to her. And at that point, it becomes clear.
This isn’t just a strange story anymore. Social Services had received multiple complaints about this family and now everything is starting to come together into something much darker. All right, quick pause here. I’m really curious where you’re watching from. Drop your city and the time where you are right now in the comments.
Appreciate it and let’s keep going. Social Services had looked into this family before and at the time, they found no violations. Reports said Erica didn’t appear afraid. But now, as investigators began speaking with relatives, a very different picture started to emerge. There were troubling accounts, alarming statements, but Casey denied everything, insisting her entire family was lying.
She even claimed her own mother had pressured the children into making up these stories. Her attorney backed her up, arguing there was no real evidence and that the couple was actually doing everything they could to find Erica. But the problem wasn’t just what Casey was saying, the problem was that none of her versions actually made sense.
At first, Erica was supposedly living with her grandmother, then the story shifted again. Suddenly, there was a mysterious woman from Facebook, a woman who later disappeared along with her account and phone number. Then Casey claimed they had never even been to that house, that they had only seen it in photos.
Later, she said Erica simply didn’t want to come back. At one point, she even showed Social Services a completely different girl with the same name and tried to convince them that this was their child. And every single time the story changed, investigators checked everything they could, databases, records, Social Security information, but the result was always the same, nothing.
No documents issued, no activity, no trace of Erica after 2011. It was as if she had simply vanished from reality. Meanwhile, the case began to shake the entire community. People held vigils, they prayed, they put up billboards with her name and photo, hoping for any kind of sign. And during all of this, Casey and Sandy quietly packed their things and left the area, claiming they wanted to avoid media attention.
Then another detail surfaced, one that completely unraveled their story. Sandy’s stepfather told reporters he had only seen Erica a few times a year and the last time was back in 2008 or 2009, long before she was ever officially reported missing. At that point, investigators knew this wasn’t just a confusing case with conflicting stories anymore.
People don’t just disappear without a trace like that. Nearly a year passed, no answers, no leads, and then everything changed. Armed agents stormed the Parsons home. Casey and Sandy were arrested, but not for the disappearance of a child. They were charged with 76 counts of fraud. The charges included embezzlement of government funds, mail fraud, tax fraud, conspiracy to commit fraud against the government, and identity theft.
According to investigators, Casey and Sandy had been collecting government benefits for Erica for years. Adoption assistance, Medicaid, social security, and more. But there was one problem. Those payments were being made for a child who was no longer living with them. Even more disturbing, investigators believed Casey had been using other people’s personal information, listing them as dependents, and submitting false information on federal tax returns.
In total, 76 counts of fraud, electronic monitoring, and strict supervision while awaiting trial. But it was during this process that something far more disturbing began to surface. One by one, family members took the stand. And what they described, honestly, it didn’t even sound real. Casey’s sister, Robin, testified that she had once been asked to take Erica in so Casey wouldn’t kill her.
She spoke about constant bruises, repeated beatings, and how Casey couldn’t even look the girl in the face. Jamie confirmed it, and his account was even more brutal. Erica wasn’t allowed to use the bathroom. She was forced to eat dog food or food taken straight from the trash. She had to drink from a dog bowl. She was starved, isolated from the rest of the family, locked in a closet, and punished harshly for any so-called mistake.
She slept on the floor because she never had her own bed. He recalled how Casey pressed her hand against a hot stove, how her fingers were broken, how she was beaten with a belt, and how Sandy punched her in the head. And then came the part that’s hardest to hear. Jamie admitted that he, along with the other children, had also taken part in the abuse.
His sister, Brooke, testified that instead of taking Erica to a doctor, they sent the kids to Walmart to buy first aid supplies to try and treat her broken arm themselves. 12-year-old Sadie said she would secretly bring Erica food. She also described one moment when Casey strangled her so severely that Erica couldn’t breathe.
And with every new testimony, the picture became darker and darker. Prosecutor Anand Ramaswamy reminded the court of a statement that felt especially chilling. At one point, Sandy had said that no one would ever find Erica because Casey was smarter than the FBI. A week before she was last seen, Erica already looked severely malnourished.
Sunken eyes, pale gray skin, open wounds. Jamie said she looked like a zombie. She complained that she felt sick, that she couldn’t breathe properly. And her mother’s response was simple. “I don’t care. Go back to the corner.” The next day, the parents weren’t home. They returned later. Sandy was silent, looking like he might throw up, while Casey remained completely calm.
When Jamie asked where his sister was, the answer hadn’t changed. “She’s with her grandmother.” And that’s when prosecutor Anand Ramaswamy made a statement that essentially shattered the entire story. “Erica is no longer alive.” There was an agreement between Casey Parsons and her husband not to report her death. Sandy’s attorney argued that even serious parenting mistakes on their own don’t necessarily amount to a crime.
He emphasized that much of the case relied heavily on Jamie Parsons’ testimony. And at one point, things really did start to feel complicated. Jamie admitted that it wasn’t until 2013 that he first told his grandmother, Shirley, that he hadn’t seen Erica in a long time. And only 5 months later did he finally go to the police.
After that, Sandy’s brother, Scott, went even further, calling Jamie a pathological liar. At that point, it almost felt like the truth was getting lost, buried under conflicting stories. But then, others began to speak. Casey’s mother, Shirley, recalled that the last time she saw Erica was in late 2011. Even before that, she had noticed bruises and injuries, but Casey had convinced everyone that Jamie was responsible, and they believed her.
Until one day, Shirley witnessed something she couldn’t ignore. She saw Casey strangling Erica so violently that her husband, James, had to step in and physically stop it. They were shocked, but they still walked away. And from there, the picture only grew darker. Robin pointed out Erica’s fingers twisted, visibly deformed, as if they had been broken.
Casey brushed it off, claiming it was just arthritis. But other testimony told a very different story, one of constant abuse, punishment, and complete isolation. The court was even shown photos of Erica standing in the corner over and over again. Even the smallest details felt disturbing. Erica wasn’t allowed to call them Mom or Dad.
She had to address them only by their names, Casey and Sandy. At times, the cruelty was so bizarre, it was hard to process. Sandy’s stepmother, Janet, testified that on one occasion, the family went on vacation and left Erica home alone, instructing her to hide and not tell anyone She was only disciplined by Sandy and William for her Casey always felt she was the worst And even though this trial was essentially about Erica, something else was unfolding in that courtroom, something darker, something impossible to ignore. The list of witnesses kept
growing. Another piece of the puzzle And then, another story emerged. In 2013, a woman named Amy testified that Casey had contacted her about being a surrogate mother. And what followed was just as shocking. “She seemed like the perfect person to carry our child. She came across as sincere, simple, down-to-earth, and deeply religious.
The fact that she adopted Erica to keep her within the family, it honestly felt like a truly noble thing to do.” Amy said. Amy Miller said that Casey talked about Erica constantly and came across as the perfect person, so much so that the couple agreed to pay her $10,000 a month for the surrogacy.
At first, those payments were supposed to go to the church as donations. But very quickly, the money started going directly to Casey. And then, everything changed. Casey told Amy that the baby had died. And after that, she just disappeared, changed her phone number, her email, and told Amy to “Move on.” But the truth was very different.
The baby had been born alive and healthy. And instead of giving the child to the parents, the Parsons tried to sell the newborn for $110,000, claiming that the biological parents didn’t want the baby anymore. It was only by chance that Robin found Amy online. Police got involved, and the child was finally returned. Amy later said that Casey had changed completely from someone kind and sincere into a cold, manipulative person.
And what her family went through, she described as nothing short of hell. In the end, Casey pleaded guilty to multiple federal charges, fraud, identity theft, conspiracy, filing false tax returns, and was sentenced to 120 months in prison. Sandy was also found guilty on dozens of counts and sentenced to 96 months, along with millions of dollars in restitution.
But even that wasn’t the most important part of this story. When the sentence was delivered, the judge said something that, honestly, everyone had already started to realize. The evidence that Erica was no longer alive was overwhelming. He turned directly to Casey and told her that what she and her husband had done to that child was truly horrific.
He said he had sentenced thousands of people over the years, but no case had ever affected him like this one. And that they had made a conscious decision to get rid of the child and then cover it up. The judge also made it clear the story about Nan was nothing but a lie. And Erica was a defenseless little girl who just wanted to be loved.
After the sentencing, Casey’s sister, Robin, said this was a form of justice, but not full justice, because, as she put it, Erica deserved more. 10 years for one, 12 years for the other. Um even though he says he has no reasons to believe my child to be alive, I will go ahead, as hard as this is for me to say, I have not made any inklings one way or the other since this report came out.
My heart, my gut, and my soul tell me my child is no longer alive. But I want media, everybody who supports, loves, and prays for Erica and myself to understand that does not mean I give up. That does not mean I quit searching. That does not mean that I want anybody to give up. Until there is a body, until the DNA or whatever for sure comes from the FBI that she is passed away, Don’t give up looking.
Don’t give up praying. Don’t give up hope. Even after the sentencing, the story didn’t get any clearer. Casey’s mother, Shirley, argued that the court shouldn’t have considered any testimony about Erica at all, not without real proof that something had actually happened to her. According to her, it was all just Jamie’s words.
And right at that point, the case takes another strange turn because Jamie himself later walks back part of his statements, explaining that he wasn’t actually a direct witness to the abuse, even though he was genuinely worried about his sister. And honestly, that only makes everything more confusing because the case already felt unstable, full of contradictions, and now the truth seems even harder to pin down.
Despite all that, the attempts to overturn the convictions fail. Sandy’s appeal is rejected by the Supreme Court of the United States, and Casey’s appeal is denied as well. But even then, people don’t stop. The local community comes together to keep searching for Erica, bringing in search dog specialists, organizing field searches, checking different areas just because they refuse to let her story fade away.
They keep saying the same thing, she’s not trash, she’s a little girl and she deserves to be found. People give their time, their energy, everything they have, but there are no results, no trace, no answers, and still, they don’t give up because as they put it, they’re not just searching for Erica as someone who might be gone, they’re also searching for the possibility that she’s still alive somewhere.
Later, an age-progressed image of Erica is created with the hope that someone, somewhere, might recognize her face, that someone will remember, that someone will finally speak up. But the years keep passing and even 5 years after she was officially declared missing, there are still no answers. Brooke, the oldest daughter of Casey and Sandy, eventually agreed to cooperate with the Federal Bureau of Investigation and give an official statement.
Up until that point, she had supported her parents, but what she told investigators was genuinely disturbing. She described one incident where her mother forced Erica to stand outside barefoot on a hot day, refusing to let her come back inside until blisters formed on her feet. Brooke said Erica’s skin looked unnatural and her body was covered in open wounds.
A few months later, Brooke visited her father in prison and that conversation became a turning point in the entire investigation. That’s when Sandy said he was ready to cooperate with law enforcement and help them find Erica. Sheriff Kevin Orton of Rowan County later said that after speaking with Sandy, investigators finally got the answers they had been searching for.
According to him, Casey claimed that on December 17th, 2011, Erica had supposedly taken her own life. He explained that the body was covered in bleach in an attempt to hide the smell, then placed into plastic bags and a storage container. And despite all of that, that same day, the couple went to a holiday party.
The next day, December 18th, Sandy said they drove to Pageland, where he began digging a hole. The remains were taken out of the container. Casey removed Erica’s clothing and then the child was buried in a shallow grave. According to Sandy, the container and the clothes were later thrown away. He also said that it was his wife who instructed him to stick to the story about Nan.
The skeletal human remains of Erica Parsons were discovered on Tuesday. Law enforcement sources telling our NBC affiliate WCNC that her remains were found in Chesterfield County, South Carolina, some 40 miles southeast of Charlotte. Now, Erica was last seen in 2011 when she was just 13 years old, but family didn’t report her missing until 2013, nearly a year and a half later.
Sandy led investigators to a specific area in the woods. That’s where, in a shallow grave, the remains of Erica Parsons were eventually found. “That day in South Carolina was incredibly difficult for all of us,” Sheriff Orton said. “I’ve seen a lot of seasoned officers and even they struggled with what we found.
” According to him, the deputies escorting Sandy walked him into the wooded area and less than a minute later, they came back out. Sandy was crying. Sheriff Jay Brooks said that Erica’s family came to the burial site and many of those present couldn’t hold back their emotions. Teresa Goodman, Erica’s aunt, explained that, according to officials, a deal had been made with Sandy.
She also shared that she had previously searched that same area with a private investigator, but at the time, they found nothing. “I’m grateful that the family who cared about her was able to get at least some sense of closure,” Teresa said. “The Rowan County Sheriff’s Office deserves the highest respect,” Brooks added.
“They put in thousands and thousands of man-hours on this case. You can’t go through something like this and not stop to reflect. When you leave here, call your kids.” Detective Chad Moose received a call from Casey Parsons, who claimed she had important information. She said that Erica had repeatedly talked about wanting to die and later, according to Casey, she found the girl lying on a blanket on the living room floor.
Casey said she turned Erica over, but there were no signs of life. She claimed that Erica had taken her own life. Over time, that story changed with multiple different versions of how, according to Casey, Erica had died. Casey said that afterward, Erica’s remains were placed in a container and that Sandy instructed her to pour bleach over the body.
Bank records later showed that bleach had been purchased at Walmart on December 5th. Casey also admitted that she had bent Erica’s fingers backward, but denied breaking them. Only years later did she acknowledge that some of Erica’s fingers may, in fact, have been broken. Casey also confirmed that she had beaten Erica with a belt that had a metal buckle.
She said she was afraid to seek medical help because she feared her sister, Robin, would involve social services. At First Baptist Church, family members, strangers, and law enforcement officers gathered to say goodbye to Erica. The service took place just before what would have been her birthday, nearly a year after the discovery of her remains.
Around that same time, the autopsy results were released. Sheriff Orton had previously said that charges would be delayed until the forensic findings came in and when they finally did, they painted a devastating picture of what Erica had endured. According to the medical examiner’s report, Erica’s death was the result of intentional violence that ultimately proved fatal, although the exact mechanism of death could not be determined.
Investigators documented multiple fractures at different stages of healing in the upper part of her right arm, in the bone connecting the arm to the collarbone, in a finger, her jaw, her nose, her left shin, and seven ribs, with some of those ribs having been broken more than once. In addition, experts found evidence of spinal trauma along with severe exhaustion, dehydration, and malnutrition.
They also noted signs of reduced bone density and delayed physical development. One tooth was missing and there were clear indications that several others had been broken. Investigators also couldn’t rule out the possibility that Erica may have been suffering from kidney failure, untreated sepsis or infection, and even potential poisoning remained on the table.
“Given the history of physical abuse and the signs of bodily injury identified during the autopsy, we cannot rule out the possibility of fatal blunt force trauma, suffocation, or strangulation,” the medical examiner wrote in the report. It was also officially confirmed that her body had been dismembered.
Although Carolyn Parsons said she was grateful that Erica was eventually found after Sandy led investigators to the burial site, she made one thing very clear in her view. “That didn’t erase his responsibility in any way. He stood right behind her and supported every lie that came out of her mouth,” Carolyn said. We’ve learned her adopted parents, Sandy and Casey Parsons, will be charged with first-degree murder.
The Parsons have always denied they had anything to do with the disappearance of the little girl. Sheriff Kevin Orton, who announced the indictments here today, said there were times during the investigation he thought this day would never come, but it did because he said investigators never gave up.
We just did not want to leave a little girl out there. We want to bring her home. Now, the Parsons will be brought back to Salisbury to face charges in her death. There people that uh think the Parsons should have already been hung on the square and uh you know, they’ll have their day in court and we’ll let the the jury decide their fate.
According to the indictment, Casey and Sandy Parsons were officially charged with first-degree murder, felony child abuse resulting in serious bodily injury, concealment of death, and obstruction of justice. The document stated that Casey and Sandy knowingly and intentionally dismembered and destroyed the human remains of Erica Lynn Parsons using various methods including removing parts of the body and physically destroying the remains.
As Sheriff Kevin Orton explained, this case weighed heavily on everyone involved. He said he had been in the job for 30 years, some of his investigators even longer, and they all felt the same pressure that if they failed to find Erica and bring charges, it would be a complete failure of their careers.
This case, he said, carried an enormous emotional burden. He added that the investigation had been incredibly difficult. There were moments when they still hoped to find Erica alive and other moments when they were simply praying to recover her remains. And now, they were finally ready to move forward and take the case to trial.
The road to that point had been long and they wanted to make sure everything was done right, every detail accounted for, every question answered. He also noted that it carried special meaning that the charges were filed just before the date that would have been Erica’s 20th birthday. All right, well, in other news this afternoon, the adoptive parents of a North Carolina teen found dead years after being reported missing, well, they will have separate trials.
Sandy and Casey Parsons face multiple charges including first-degree murder. Their 13-year-old daughter Erica was last seen in 2011, but she was not reported missing for another 2 years. Sandy Parsons led authorities to that girl’s body in South Carolina in 2016. Casey Parsons is set to stand trial in April of 2020.
A trial date for his wife has not yet been set. Today should have been Erica Lynn Parsons’ 21st birthday. Instead, her biological family gathered at her gravesite in China Grove. Erica Parsons, allegedly murdered by her adopted parents back in 2011. Now, they both sit in jail waiting for their trials.
A lot has happened in the past year in this case and the family says that makes today a little different than years past. Happy birthday [singing] to you. It’s a milestone for almost everyone, your 21st birthday, but for little Erica Parsons, she’ll never get to experience that. Hey, I should be getting off work, going home, getting dressed, taking my sister out for her very first drink.
Sunday afternoon, family and friends gathered here to place flowers and gifts. I cried all the way up here. For Erica’s biological mother, Carolyn, she says this birthday’s a little different considering what we’ve seen happen in the past year. The fact that a court date was set for Casey, even though it’s in 2020, has a huge impact on how I feel about things being done.
A trial date was set this month for Casey Parsons. Casey and Sandy Parsons, Erica’s adopted parents, are both charged in the child’s death and could face the death penalty if found guilty. The two main family members are sitting where they deserve to be. I hope for the rest of their lives. But those two were not the focus today.
Erica is everybody’s angel. Erica is everybody’s story. Erica’s life and story have traveled across the nation impacting some that never even met the little girl. As long as we’re breathing, Erica’s never going to be forgotten again. For the family, this date is difficult every year. This Erica’s day. And she deserves every bit of this and more.
And as they wait for justice, they tell me they feel Erica’s presence often, not just here at her grave. But she’s not here. You can spend time with her wherever you are, wherever you’re going. At first, Carolyn Parsons pushed for the death penalty, but over time, her perspective changed. She said she wanted them to spend every single day for the rest of their lives behind bars, calling them the embodiment of evil and describing them as monsters.
Are you in fact guilty? Yes. Casey Parsons, the adopted mother of Erica Parsons, admitted to killing the little girl. She’ll now spend the rest of her life behind bars. Casey Parsons pleaded guilty to charges of first-degree murder and felony child abuse. Yeah, so much emotion inside of that courtroom today as Casey Parsons admitted that she is guilty of abusing and then murdering her adopted daughter, Erica Parsons.
Of course, this admission is shocking since Erica Parsons was reported missing in 2012. Casey and her husband, Sandy, have denied having anything to do with that disappearance. At this point, it appears that Sandy Parsons will still have to stand trial for the charges against him. We’re going to get much more information from the district attorney inside right now.
We’ll bring you the latest later. Back to you. Casey Parsons pleaded guilty to charges of child abuse and murder. The court sentenced her to life in prison without the possibility of parole. I can’t tell you why. I don’t know why I didn’t stop. I did it and I’m sorry, sorry. After years of denial, Casey Parsons openly admitted she abused then murdered her adopted daughter, Erica Parsons.
I didn’t have a steady home. I didn’t have a steady job. Had I known then what I know now, I would have risked it. I would have took her to different place than you know. Today, prosecutors shared testimony from Erica’s sibling who said Erica was choked, beaten, and neglected by Casey and Sandy.
Erica always smelled bad and his mom didn’t let her take a bath. Erica had a lot of cuts and bruises and black eyes from mom hitting her. Casey offered an apology before the judge sentenced her to life in prison with no parole on that murder charge. And I want to say I’m sorry to God and to Erica. She also admitted that many family members reached out to her trying to help her with Erica, but she said she pushed them away and eventually murdered that little girl that she was supposed to protect.
She said family members tried to step in and protect Erica. My parents and my sister reached out to me numerous times to help me. Numerous. Um I pushed them back. I would lie constantly to them. In addition to that, she received separate consecutive sentences for concealing a death, felony child abuse resulting in serious bodily injury, and obstruction of justice.
Altogether, those additional sentences added up to a total of 23 years. My first My name is Carolyn Parsons. I am Erica Lynn Parsons’ biological mother. I’ve said all along that Casey deserved life in prison versus the death sentence. I still 100% agree with that because their life in prison living, her life in prison living, will be worse than any death sentence she could ever get.
I know as far as having her other children participate, I just cannot seem to understand how. I don’t know why. But she did the one thing I wanted her to do. She at least said something. I don’t know that I believe that she is sorry. I don’t know that I believe that I didn’t mean to. Some of it I had heard. Some of it I hadn’t heard.
I still completely believe that Casey Stone Parsons has no heart. She has no soul. She is a body that is just there. She [snorts] is an individual who just functions. The only thing Casey gets is what Erica doesn’t. She gets to live. But in return for living, she will probably be in solitary confinement. And every time she gets out, she gets to listen to people talk about her, listen to people whisper about her.
She gets to wonder, “Am I going to make it back to my cell tonight?” But when that judge made that last statement, that last statement was, “And you cannot be around children.” Yeehaw! Casey loses her rights to watch her grandkids grow up. What an incredible final end for her. Four months after Casey entered her plea, Sandy also pleaded guilty to obstruction of justice, child abuse, concealment of death, and second-degree murder for his role in Erica’s death.
He was sentenced to a minimum of 33 years in prison with his first chance at parole coming only at the age of 82. Sandy Parsons appeared in court this morning pleading guilty to murder and other felony charges. People might forgive me. I know God has. But I’m here to forgive myself. I tell you why I’m not. Things Erica’s gone through.
and I feel her as a dad. Attorneys argued Sandy was manipulated and controlled by his wife, Casey. They said it was Casey who committed most of the abuse against Erica, locking her in a closet, starving and severely beating the girl. They say one day Casey told Sandy that Erica died and manipulated him into covering it up, burying her body in a South Carolina field and lying to police for years.
Sandy Parson’s role as I stated was substantially less than that of Casey Parsons. There is literally no evidence that Sandy Parsons personally intended to kill or seriously injure Erica Parsons. They asked the judge for leniency in sentencing. Rather than the near 80 years he could have received, the judge sentenced him to a maximum of 43 years.
Erica’s biological mother was in court today as well, getting to tell Sandy what she thought of him. I stand by what I have said from day one. Which is I used to love you, now I hate you. And he got to hear that today. In court, Sandy’s attorney read letters from his two youngest children. They wrote that they loved their father and missed him, insisting he had never hurt them.
Psychologist Claudia Coleman described Sandy as a passive person who struggled to make decisions on his own, saying that Casey held the dominant role in the family and could threaten him using the children. She also believed that Sandy didn’t intend for Erica to die and didn’t fully understand the extent of what was happening.
But the prosecution saw it very differently. They argued that Sandy was an adult, he saw the abuse, and at times even participated in it. So he couldn’t be seen as a victim or a bystander. And because of that, they said he deserved the maximum sentence. Carolyn Parsons called the sentence too lenient, saying he had a choice and that other family members could have stepped in as well, but didn’t.
The judge agreed with that perspective. He acknowledged that while Casey may have been the mastermind, Sandy followed her, took part in the crimes, and in his words, had a distorted mind. And in the end, the case was closed. After thousands of hours of work, hundreds of interviews, and extensive searches, the truth became clear.
Sheriff Kevin Orton said this investigation was never about departments or agencies, it was always about Erica. They moved carefully, step-by-step, building a case that couldn’t be torn apart. Prosecutor Cook added that society has to find the courage to be a voice for those who cannot speak for themselves and that child abuse is one of the worst things that exists.
But maybe the most powerful words came from her mother. Carolyn said she gave Erica up because she truly believed her daughter would have a better life. She called her a gift, the kind of gift millions of people would want. And then, she said just one thing. She only wants to know why. And she knows she will never get that answer.
And that’s where this story ends. But cases like this are a reminder that reality can sometimes be more terrifying than anything you’d see in a movie or a fictional story. Behind every case like this, there are real people, real events, and questions that sometimes are never answered. If you found this story compelling, consider supporting the channel, leave a like, share your thoughts in the comments, and make sure you’re subscribed so you don’t miss what’s coming next.
Because there are still many more stories ahead, mysterious, disturbing, and impossible to forget.
