Around 4:30 in the morning, in one of Austin’s upscale neighborhoods, the quiet night was suddenly broken by dogs barking nonstop. Ted Shaughnessy picked up his pistol and stepped into the hallway, ready to protect the life he had spent 30 years building. But within seconds, he would be on the kitchen floor, badly wounded and fighting for his life.
From the outside, the Shaughnessy family looked like a picture of success. They owned a respected jewelry business, lived in a beautiful home, and years earlier, they had adopted a 16-month-old boy from an orphanage in Ukraine. To Ted and Cory, that little boy became the brightest part of their world. But 18 years later, that same light would be replaced by something cold, selfish, and carefully planned.
This is the story of a $6 million inheritance, a hidden marriage, and a son who made the unthinkable choice to turn against the parents who had given him everything. For decades, the Shaughnessy family seemed to represent the American dream. Their story was built on hard work, lasting love, and the kind of respect in the community that most people only read about.
Before we continue, please help this channel grow. Like the video, leave a comment, and subscribe for more true stories. It really helps us. Thank you. To understand what happened in March 2018, I need to go back to the man at the center of it all, Theodore Shaughnessy. Most people knew him simply as Ted. He was born on February 7th, 1963, the youngest of three brothers, and he grew up in the dry, sun-baked landscape of Arizona, not far from Phoenix.
His brothers, Tim and Tom, remembered Ted as a kid with restless energy, like he was always searching for the next thrill. And from a young age, one thing became part of who he was, speed. For Ted, fast cars were not just a hobby. They were part of his personality. He felt most alive when the world around him rushed by in a blur.
As a teenager, he loved karting. As an adult, he moved on to powerful cars. People close to him said he was almost fearless behind the wheel, but that love for speed did not mean Ted lived carelessly. In everyday life, he was grounded, warm, and easy to like. He had the kind of presence that naturally pulled people in.
In the early 1980s, Ted’s life changed when he met Cory Gammel. From the beginning, they connected in a way that felt natural. They shared similar interests, values, and ambitions, and it did not take long before they decided to build a life together. They got married, moved to Austin, Texas, and there they created their shared dream, a high-end jewelry business called Jewelry Gallery.
The store worked because Ted and Cory balanced each other perfectly. Cory was the quiet force behind the scenes. She had studied fine arts and gemology in college and became a skilled appraiser. Her work was careful and detailed, focused on diamonds, emeralds, and the small qualities that gave each piece its value.
Ted became the face of the business. He had a natural gift for talking to people. Anyone who walked into the store could feel comfortable around him. He was not just selling jewelry. He was building trust, and he could make a stranger feel like an old friend within minutes. By 2000, Jewelry Gallery had become well-known among Austin’s elite.
The business was thriving, and Ted and Cory were able to buy a beautiful home in a respected neighborhood close to their store. But even with the successful business, the nice house, and the life they had built, something was missing. They wanted to be parents more than anything, but they could not have children of their own.
That longing took them across the world to Ukraine in the spring of 2000. There, they found Nicholas, the little boy they would call Nick. He was only 16 months old, but from the moment they met him, he became the center of their lives. By all accounts, Ted and Cory were devoted, loving parents. They fell in love with Nick right away, and Ted especially embraced fatherhood with a joy and dedication that surprised even the people who knew him best.
He became the kind of father who wanted to be there for every moment and rarely wanted to be away from his son. As Nick got older, he began to resemble his father more and more. He was handsome, smart, and carried that same deep hunger for speed that had always been part of Ted. Ted and Nick spent countless hours at racing tracks together.
For them, it was not just about cars. It was the roar of engines, the smell of burnt rubber, and a bond only the two of them seem to fully understand. But, Nick did not only inherit Ted’s love for fast cars. He also seemed to pick up the business mindset that had helped Ted and Corey build their success. Even in middle school, Nick was already finding ways to make money, selling chocolate bars to classmates.
By high school, he had started a car repair business that did surprisingly well for a teenager, even hiring several people to help him keep up. From the outside, the Shaughnessys looked like the perfect family. Ted and Corey were successful, loving parents, and Nick was the bright, ambitious son. Their home seemed built on love, respect, and drive.
They also had two dogs, Bart and Breena, who were treated like family. Most days, Ted and Corey even brought them to the jewelry store. Ted’s reputation in the community was strong. People knew him as generous, that the kind of man who might pay for a stranger’s groceries or lend money to a friend without expecting anything extra.
He helped because he truly cared, not because he wanted attention. That was one reason his fate was so hard for people to accept. By 2018, the Shaughnessy family seemed to be standing at the top of the life they had worked so hard to build. What they did not know was that the boy they had adopted from a Ukrainian orphanage 18 years earlier was now heading towards something dark and almost impossible to believe.
Nick’s life took a major turn in 2015 when he met Jaclyn Alexa Edison, known to most people as Jackie. She had recently moved from New Jersey to Texas and for 19-year-old Mick, the attraction was immediate and intense. After graduation, Nick and Jackie became nearly inseparable. They tied their lives together so tightly that looking back, it probably should have raised concern.
They eventually left Austin and moved to College Station. Jackie enrolled at Texas A&M University to study engineering while Nick tried to make money as a day trader from their shared home. At first, Ted and Cory saw the relationship as a normal part of Nick growing up and becoming independent. Every weekend, Nick and Jackie drove about 2 hours back to Austin to visit them keeping up the appearance of a close, loving family.
But underneath that image, things were starting to crack. Much of the tensions came from the same business instincts Ted and Cory had once admired in their son. Nick had always known how to hustle, but stock trading was not like selling candy or fixing cars. The risks were bigger and the results were far less reliable.
The gap between Nick’s ambitions and his real financial situation was mostly covered by his parents. Ted and Cory had loaned him $30,000, money meant to support his education. They also paid regular expenses including his car insurance and gas. Even Ted’s close friend, Ted Cole, gave Nick $5,000 to invest for him showing how much faith people still had in Nick’s potential.
But Nick was supposed to pay the money back. As his trading losses grew and his spending became more expensive, that promise started falling apart. In the months before the tragedy, the tension reached a breaking point. Ted and Cory were frustrated not only because Nick was not repaying them, but also because he showed little interest in a traditional college path.
They watched as the $30,000 meant for his future went toward expensive furniture and stylish clothes for him and Jackie. Each time the couple visited Austin, they seemed to show off something new, even though their bank accounts were nearly empty, reportedly holding less than $2. Eventually, Ted and Cory made a difficult decision.
They cut off the money and warned Nick that once the funds were gone, he would have to get a job and support himself. That decision caused a serious conflict. For a short time, Nick appeared to change course and even began returning some money, but the resentment never disappeared. It only went quiet.
Deep down, Nick believed he deserved the lifestyle his parents had built. And to him, the idea of working a regular job, whether with his hands or behind a desk, felt unbearable. What Ted and Cory did not know, and what no one close to the family suspected, was that Nick and Jackie had already made a huge decision behind everyone’s back.
In the summer of 2017, about 8 months before Ted lost his life, Nick and Jackie secretly got married. They hid that marriage from the same people who were still helping pay for their lifestyle. And that secrecy showed just how far Nick had drifted from the values Ted and Cory had tried to teach him. For Nick and Jackie, the secret marriage seemed to create an us against everyone mindset.
They were living in their own bubble, and inside it, their money problems were growing into something much darker. Later, digital evidence would show just how desperate things had become. While they tried to look like a successful young couple in front of family and friends, their private messages told a different story. Behind closed doors, everything was falling apart.
They were being pressured over unpaid debts. One debt was $2,600 owed to a neighbor who was threatening to tell Nick’s parents parent about his surveillance activity if he did not pay. For Nick, it must have felt like everything was closing in. But instead of seeing Ted and Cory as the loving parents who had brought him from a Ukrainian orphanage and given him a life, he started seeing them as people standing between him and an inheritance he believed should already be his.
In his distorted thinking, they were no longer his parents, they were obstacles. Nick began focusing on the $1 million life insurance policies on each parent, along with the family home and jewelry gallery, valued together at around $6 million. And these were not just passing thoughts, they were the beginning of a plan.
He even started testing the idea with a few people he knew, including Spencer Patterson, offering huge amounts of money in exchange for removing his parents from the picture. By this point, Nick’s change was almost complete. The smart, good-looking young man people thought they knew was becoming cold, calculating, and dangerous. He had convinced himself, and seemingly Jackie too, that the only way to secure the life they wanted was to take away the lives of the two people who had given him everything.
This was not a sudden reaction to one argument. It was a careful plan meant to look like a random home attack in a city already worried about violence. Nick knew his parents’ routines. He knew the weak points in their home security, and he knew how to use the blind spots inside their own house against them. By late February 2018, the pieces were in place.
The son who had once been the light of Ted and Cory’s lives was now preparing to bring permanent darkness into their home. Through all of this, Jackie stayed by Nick’s side. Later, Nick would describe her as his main support system. And while Jackie would eventually try to distance herself from what happened, deleted messages on her phone suggested she was not just standing in the background.
She was part of the lies, part of the financial collapse, and eventually part of the countdown to the early morning of March 2. Everything was now set for a betrayal so deep that it would shake Austin and leave people struggling to understand how this could happen inside an adoptive family. The painful irony was that Ted and Cory were still thinking about Nick’s future.
They hoped he would find his way, maybe even take over the family business one day. But Nick was already looking at that same legacy in the coldest way possible. He did not want the hard work behind jewelry gallery. He wanted the money it had created, and he wanted it now. The love that once filled the Shaughnessy home was being replaced by cold, selfish calculation.
Ted, the fearless man who loved speed, was about to be blindsided by a threat he never could have imagined. The boy he had taught to drive, the son he once hated to be away from, was now the person planning his end. On March 2, 2018, the quiet of a respected Austin neighborhood was broken by events that would leave a family destroyed and a community in disbelief.
It was 4:30 in the morning, the kind of hour when most people are still deep asleep. Inside the beautiful Shaughnessy home, Ted and Cory were sleeping peacefully, just like they had for decades together. The calm inside the house was suddenly broken by Brina, Brina, the family dog, barking in a frantic, non-stop way.
In a home with pets, nighttime barking does not always mean danger. Dogs can react to noises outside, passing cars, or things people cannot even hear. But this time, something about it made Ted get up. Ted Shaughnessy, the man his brothers described as fearless, did not hesitate. He grabbed the .45 caliber pistol he kept for protection and stepped out of the bedroom to see what had scared the dogs.
Cory had heard the dogs bark at night before, so at first she settled back into her pillow, hoping to get a little more sleep. She had no idea her husband had just walked into a deadly trap. The shift from quiet to chaos happened in seconds. Just as Cory closed her eyes again, a sharp gunshot cracked through the house from the kitchen.
Then several more shots followed. She sat up fast, suddenly wide awake, with fear and adrenaline taking over. Cory grabbed her own weapon, a .357 caliber revolver she kept above the bed, and moved toward the bedroom door. What she saw through that doorway was a nightmare. A stranger was coming toward the bedroom, and right in front of her, he shot Bart, her beloved dog.
With no time to think, Cory fired back. She pulled the trigger again and again, emptying the revolver toward the intruder. The house filled with the smell of gunpowder and the ringing echo of shots. Once the weapon was empty, Cory backed into the bedroom closet, the only place she could hide. Shaking and defenseless, she called 911.
As she spoke with the dispatcher, the sounds inside the house were unbearable. Through tears, Cory reported what had happened while low moans came from somewhere outside the closet. She did not know if the sounds were coming from the intruder or from Ted, lying somewhere and fighting for his life. Desperate to find out, she told the operator she was going to check on him, but the dispatcher firmly told her to stay hidden until officers arrived.
For 15 minutes, Cory sat in the dark closet, listening as the house slowly went quiet and the moaning stopped. She bit her hands until they bled, trying to hold back the screams in her throat. She prayed Ted was still alive, even as that hope began to fall apart. Finally, the dispatcher told her the police were near the house.
Cory crawled out of the closet and slowly moved down the hallway toward the front door. To get there, she had to pass the kitchen, and that was where the full horror of the night hit her. Ted Shaughnessy, the man she had loved for 30 years, her husband, business partner, and best friend, was lying lifeless on the floor.
Blood surrounded him, and spent shell casings were scattered nearby. Moving like she was in a fog, Cory forced herself past him and reached the front door. But when she opened it, no one was there. There were no officers on the porch. There were no intruders, either. In a cruel twist, the responding officers had mixed up the house numbers and were knocking on the neighbors’ doors instead.
When police finally reached the correct home, they found Cory completely overwhelmed, shaking as if her body could not process what had happened. She could not explain everything clearly. All she could do was point inside the house and repeat one name, Ted. In that moment, Cory felt like her own life had ended, too. It seemed impossible that anything, good or bad, could ever matter again.
Officers secured the scene and placed a devastated Cory in a patrol car while they moved through the house. At 5:14 a.m., Theodore Shaughnessy was officially pronounced dead. He had been shot four times. As daylight began to break over Austin, Cory found enough strength to call her son, Nick. She told the 19-year-old that his father had been shot.
Nick seemed completely stunned and tried to get more details, but Cory could only tell him she needed him there. Nick and Jackie immediately left College Station and drove two hours back to the home that had seemed safe only a few hours earlier. They arrived around 8:20 a.m. Beginning a 3-month stay where they comforted Cory as she struggled through unbearable grief.
For the first time in 30 years, Cory was alone inside that large house. She was grieving not only Ted, but also Bart, one of the dogs who had become part of the family they built when they could not have more children. News of the night time attack spread through the community almost immediately. People could not understand why anyone would target a man like Ted Shaughnessy.
He was respected, generous, and still at an age when he should have been enjoying the life he had worked so hard to build. Friends and neighbors gathered around Cory trying to help her face a world without him. Ted was the kind of man who would have put himself in danger to help somebody else.
He deserved to grow old, but instead, someone had destroyed his family in one violent morning. The investigation began before sunrise on March 2nd, 2018. Detectives moved through what had once been a warm, successful home, but now the kitchen had become a cold and devastating crime scene. As they documented the area, investigators found the first sign that this may not have been done by one person.
Near Ted’s body, they discovered shell casings from two different calibers, .4 caliber and .380 caliber rounds. That detail suggested at least two shooters may have been involved, but what detectives did not find was just as important. There was no clear sign of forced entry. The doors were not damaged and the locks were still intact, which made investigators wonder if the attackers had a key or inside knowledge of the home.
The only strange point of entry was in Cheyna Shayna’s old bedroom. A window was open and the screen had been pushed outward, almost like someone had used it to get in or out. Investigators lifted one clear fingerprint from the glass and sent it for testing. That window quickly became one of the most important details in the case.
In that same room, detectives found an empty box in a dresser. It had once held a .40 caliber pistol and strangely, that seemed to be the only thing missing from the entire house. This was a home filled with expensive electronics, artwork, and jewelry, but none of it had been taken. The intruders ignored everything and took one specific weapon.
That same weapon was later used in the attack on Ted. If the people inside knew exactly where to find one gun among about 20 pistols, then this did not look random. It looked targeted. Still, the first theory police followed was a robbery gone wrong. The Shaynasies were known in a business connected to valuable jewelry, so it seemed possible someone had followed that wealth back to their home.
Corey wanted to believe that, too. A failed robbery was horrible enough, but the idea of a personal betrayal was almost impossible to accept. But the security system told a different story. It showed that the bedroom window had been opened at 4:27 a.m. and the sound of glass breaking in the kitchen was recorded 17 minutes later at 4:44 a.m.
That meant the intruders may have been inside the house for 17 minutes before the violence started. They had time to search for valuables, demand the safe code, or take what they wanted, but they did not do that. Instead, they waited in the dark until Ted came across them, which made the robbery theory harder to believe.
When Nick first spoke with investigators, he gave them possible leads that pointed away from the family. He told them about an incident from the 1990s when Ted had managed a pawn shop and wounded an armed robber during a shootout. Nick suggested those men may have gotten out of prison and come back years later for revenge.
Detectives checked the story, but it led nowhere. There was no evidence placing those former criminals near Austin when Ted was killed. Then Nick gave them an even more complicated theory. He claimed a neighbor had hired him to watch her allegedly unfaithful husband. According to Nick, he had placed a tracker on the man’s car, and the husband may have found out.
Nick suggested the husband could have hired people to target his wife, but they went to the wrong house because both families drove white Mercedes. The neighbor did confirm that she had paid Nick to do surveillance work for her, but she dismissed the idea that her life was ever in danger, and detectives found no evidence that her husband even knew he was being watched.
As those outside theories started falling apart, the investigation slowly turned back toward the family. And that protective shield of family loyalty began to crack. For a while, investigators even looked closely at Cory. They could not understand why the intruders had left her alive after she fired several shots at them.
On top of that, Cory was the only beneficiary of Ted’s $1 million life insurance policy. When she later asked about the payout while the case was still active, police thought it made her look cold and calculating. Cory was crushed when she found out she was being treated as a suspect. In her mind, asking about the insurance money was not greed, it was survival.
The family business was struggling without Ted because he had been the public face of Jewelry Gallery. His warmth, charm, and customer relationships had held so much of it together. While Corey was under suspicion, police finally got the results from the fingerprint on the bedroom window, but it did not belong to a killer. The print matched a window company employee from Minnesota who had installed the windows years earlier.
Once again, investigators had hit another dead end in a case full of disappearing leads. Then something Nick had said during his own interview came back into focus. He had mentioned that he often used that same bedroom window as a secret way to get in and out of the house without his parents knowing. When detectives asked who else knew about that hidden entry point, Nick quickly gave them a name, his close friend, Spencer Patterson.
That was the moment the investigation began shifting away from Corey and toward her own son. From there, finding the weapons became the main goal. Detectives were looking for the .40 caliber and .38 caliber pistols connected to the shooting. During another conversation, Nick casually mentioned that he had given Spencer a .380 caliber pistol.
When police searched Spencer’s car, they found the weapon exactly where Nick said it would be. But ballistic testing showed it was not the weapon used in the crime. And once Spencer realized his best friend might be trying to frame him, he finally started talking. Spencer told investigators that Nick had not only told him about the window, but had once offered him money to kill Ted and Corey.
According to Spencer, Nick bragged about a $6 million inheritance he would get once his parents were gone. At that point, the search for a failed robbery was over. Now detectives were looking at the possibility of a hired killing. As investigators focused more closely on Nicholas Shaughnessy, the case moved into a new and much more serious phase.
This time, detectives began digging through his digital life. Nick’s behavior after Ted’s death had already made experienced officers uncomfortable. While Corey looked destroyed by grief, Nick seemed strangely energized by what his father’s death might bring him. Witnesses saw him joking and laughing with police.
And when officers asked him to take a gunshot residue test, he jumped into the movement almost like an excited kid. That emotional disconnect stood out. So did his intense curiosity about forensic details from the scene. To investigators, Nick looked less like a grieving son and more like someone pretending to be one.
The breakthrough came from the same technology Nick used every day. Police seized both his phone and Jackie’s phone. What they found was a digital trail of betrayal. Nick and Jackie had tried to delete large amounts of data, but they had not erased everything. There were suspicious 2-hour gaps in their phone activity, but forensic experts were still able to recover a huge amount of damaging information.
One of the biggest discoveries was their secret marriage certificate. Nick and Jackie had been married since the summer of 2017. They had hidden that fact from Ted and Corey while still living off the student money his parents had provided. But that lie was only the beginning. Recovered messages showed the newlyweds were in serious financial trouble with less less than $2 in their bank accounts.
They were drowning in debt and facing threats of exposure from neighbors. And slowly, the motive became painfully clear: desperation mixed with greed. The digital evidence became worse with every file investigators recovered. Records showed Nick had accessed his parents’ home security system at 5:39 a.m. on the morning of the shooting.
That was almost 2 hours before where supposedly learned what happened from Corey’s frantic phone call. In other words, Nick already knew something had happened at the house, and investigators believed he knew because he had helped make it happen. Then, during a search of Nick and Jackie’s townhouse in College Station, police found a box of ammunition that matched the .
380 caliber casings discovered in the Shaughnessy kitchen. Even more disturbing, exactly six bullets were missing from the tray. While Nick tried to shift suspicion onto his friend Spencer Patterson, Spencer’s own interview gave investigators a piece they could not ignore. Spencer admitted that Nick had directly offered him money to kill Ted and Corey.
According to him, Nick talked about the $6 million estate he expected to inherit, along with millions more in insurance money once his parents were gone. That changed the entire case. This was no longer just a suspicious death or a strange home invasion. Investigators were now looking at a planned murder-for-hire plot. The search for the people who actually pulled the triggers led detectives to surveillance footage from February 28th, only 2 days before Ted was killed.
The cameras showed two men entering the home Nick shared with Jackie. From there, investigators identified them as 21-year-old Johnny Leon and Arian Smith. And once detectives began confronting people with the evidence, the whole plan started to fall apart from the outside in.
Johnny Leon admitted that Nick had offered him $100,000 to Ted and Corey. He also revealed something even more disturbing. On the day the plan first began, Nick had driven with Leon to the Austin house, supposedly planning to do it himself. But at the last moment, the son Ted and Corey had loved more than anything said he could not go through with it personally.
Instead, he chose to pay others to target the parents who had brought him out of a Ukrainian orphanage 18 years earlier. Arian Smith, the second gunman, gave investigators a confession that was just as chilling. He admitted that he fired the shots that killed Ted using the family’s own .40 caliber pistol.
It was the exact weapon Nick had told them where to find. Smith explained that Nick had remotely turned off the home security system and told them how to get inside through his old bedroom window. By the time the investigation was over, the robbery story had completely fallen apart. Ted’s death had been exposed as a planned hit arranged by a son who saw his parents as nothing more than a delay between him and the money he wanted.
For Corey Shaughnessy, that discovery was like losing Ted all over again. She had to face the fact that for 3 months, she had lived with, cried with, and leaned on the very people accused of helping arrange her husband’s death. Nick’s downfall was not one dramatic moment like something out of a movie. It was a slow collapse of the image he had carefully built around himself.
On May 29th, 2018, almost exactly 3 months after gunfire tore through the Shaughnessy kitchen, the truth finally broke through the family’s denial. Nick and Jackie were arrested and charged with solicitation of capital murder, a charge that in Texas could carry the death penalty. For Corey, this was a blow that went beyond even the first shock of losing Ted.
For about 90 days, she had sheltered them, fed them, and mourned beside them. And all that time, investigators believed they were connected to the plan that valued Ted’s life at less than a comfortable lifestyle, a nice apartment and a car payment. The interviews and later testimony from Johnny Leon and Aerion Smith filled in the brutal details that Nick’s polished image had tried to hide.
Aerion Smith, who seemed deeply shaken by what he had done, eventually broke down during questioning. He admitted the crime had taken away his ability to sleep. At one point, he even said he deserved the death penalty, believing that a life had to be paid for with a life. And Smith confirmed the deepest betrayal.
Nick had not only disabled the security system, but had also told them exactly where to find the .22 caliber pistol used in the attack. The weapon inside Ted’s own home became the weapon used against him, chosen with help from the son he had loved and trusted. When detectives finally confronted Nick with the digital evidence, there was little room left for excuses.
They had the deleted messages. They had the bank records showing less than $2 in the account. And they had proof that Nick accessed the security app shortly after the shooting. At that point, Nick’s explanation moved into something even more disturbing. Instead of simply denying what happened, he tried to twist it into some kind of mercy.
According to Nick’s later statements, his father had been depressed, and by taking his life, Nick claimed he was somehow helping him, freeing him from emotional pain. Nick also tried to explain why Corey had to be targeted, too. In his mind, she would never be able to live without Ted, so leaving her alive would have been cruel.
That twisted reasoning showed just how far he had gone. By then, Nick no longer seemed to see his parents as real people with lives, feelings, and love for him. He had reduced them to a financial problem. Their existence only mattered to him because it stood between him and the money he wanted. Jackie’s interview went in a different direction.
Once she realized the case was closing in around her, she quickly tried to shift the blame onto Nick. She told investigators she had heard him talk about the plan, but claimed she thought it was just nonsense, and never believed he would actually do it. But the phone evidence told a much different story.
Deleted messages showed she was far more involved than she wanted police to believe. They also showed the money problems that had pushed both of them deeper into the plan. Still, Jackie’s willingness to give information against Nick became the thing that helped her legally. While Nick carried the center of the blame, she started building distance between herself and the worst parts of the crime.
For the Austin community, the truth was almost impossible to process. People had once seen the Shaughnessys as the perfect family. Now they had to face the fact that Ted and Corey had unknowingly raised the person who would help destroy them. The little boy they had brought from Ukraine to become the light of their lives had grown into someone who calculated what their deaths were worth.
Even when Nick later tried to sound sorry, saying he had been selfish and had ruined a perfect life, his words felt empty to many people. After all, he had taken a lifetime of love and opportunity and answered it with bullets, lies, and 3 months of pretending to grieve. For Corey, the end of the interrogation meant the end of her relationship with her son.
From the moment the handcuffs closed around his wrists, she stopped speaking to him. In the emptiness Ted left behind, Corey began writing letters to Nick. They were filled with the words of a mother who still loved the child he used to be, but could never forgive the man he had become. She never sent them.
As the court process moved forward, Corey, a woman who had spent her life studying the clarity of gemstones, found herself staring into a darkness no light could cut through. Nick, meanwhile, said he was working on himself in prison and hoping for forgiveness. But after the way he tried to justify Ted’s death as some kind of mercy, forgiveness seemed almost impossible.
The legal ending of the Shaughnessy case came with heavy sentences for some and controversial mercy for another. In April 2021, Nicholas Shaughnessy, Johnny Leon, and Aryan Smith all pleaded guilty. Each of them received 35 years in prison with the possibility of parole. For Aryan Smith, the man who fired the fatal shots, the sentence marked the end of a period filled with guilt.
For Nick, it was the beginning of a long reckoning with what he had done to the people who gave him everything. Jack Jacki Shaughnessy’s outcome was different. In June 2023, she pleaded guilty to attempted conspiracy to commit murder. She received deferred adjudication, which means she can avoid a formal conviction if she successfully completes her probation.
Her sentence included only 120 days in county jail and 10 years of probation. And as a yearly reminder of Ted’s death, she must return to jail for 2 days every year on the anniversary of the crime. While Jacki tried to return to a normal student life, the digital evidence remains a permanent record of the role she played in the plan that turned a son against his own father.
And if you made it to the end of this story, then you are a real true crime fan. Subscribe to the channel, turn on the bell notifications, and leave a like. I’ll see you in the next story.
