“They Cannot Still Be Fighting” — The Japanese General Who Refused To Believe Australians Were Alive

In August 1942, a Japanese officer opened his field diary and wrote something that made no sense. The Australians in front of him had been dead for 3 days, and they had just counterattacked. General Horii sent the same message to Rabaul twice. The Australians were destroyed. Both times, while he was writing those words, 450 Australians were still in their positions, still fighting, still dying, and still refusing to surrender.
I spent weeks going through campaign diaries at the Australian War Memorial, official histories of the Kokoda campaign, and declassified records of the Nankai Shitai to bring you this documentary. What you’re about to hear doesn’t appear in Japanese history books, or American ones. 6,000 Japanese soldiers, 450 Australians, 4 days in a village nobody had ever heard of, and a general who couldn’t explain what he was seeing. This is Isurava.
The 2/14th wasn’t born in a military academy. It was born in Victoria. April 1940. While Europe burned and the world tried to calculate how far Germany would go, in Melbourne and in the towns of northern and central Victoria, ordinary men signed a piece of paper that turned them into soldiers. Farmers, miners, mechanics, shop assistants, students, factory workers.
Not textbook heroes. Men who knew hard work because they’d never had another option. That was the 2/14th Battalion at the start. But by August 1942, when they set foot on the Kokoda Track, they were something else entirely. 1941, Syria and Lebanon. The 2/14th fought against Vichy French troops in one of the most forgotten theaters of the Second World War.
Semi-desert terrain, brutal heat, an enemy that wasn’t German, but wasn’t easy, either. They came out of it with something no training camp could teach. The certainty that they could fight and win. When they returned to Australia in 1942, the Pacific was already a different world. Japan had attacked Pearl Harbor. Singapore had fallen.
Darwin had been bombed. And the 2/14th received new orders before they’d had time to rest. Papua New Guinea. Immediately. 700 men, Middle East veterans, trained for desert and open terrain, sent to a mountain jungle none of them had ever seen. There’s the first butt of this story. The 2/14th was an extraordinary unit. Iron cohesion, combat-tested leadership, Lee-Enfield rifles and Bren guns they could use with their eyes closed.
But the Papua jungle wasn’t Syria. The Kokoda Track is a 96-km trail that crosses the Owen Stanley Range. Peaks close to 4,000 m, rain that turns the ground to knee-deep mud, humid heat that makes breathing an effort, vegetation so dense that visibility drops to 3 m in some sections, and disease. Malaria, dysentery, heat exhaustion.
By the time the 2/14th reached Isurava in late August 1942, the 700 men who had embarked had become something between 450 and 500. The rest were in hospital beds or on the jungle floor, too sick to continue. 450 operational men, many with fever, many with dysentery, all carrying the exhaustion of a march that no training in the Syrian desert had prepared them for.
And among them, the officers who were going to have to keep them standing when everything else failed. Lieutenant Colonel Arthur Key was the battalion commander. Serious, disciplined, formed in the classical British tradition. The kind of officer who earns respect for what he is, not what he says. Alongside him, coordinating the defense together with the 2/14th men, he was Lieutenant Colonel Ralph Honner of the 39th Battalion, a militia unit that had been holding on in the track for weeks with resources that would have broken any other unit. And then there were the
company commanders. Major Alan Cameron, who his men called Bandy, Captain Tony Young, who everyone called Bully, Captain Edgar Stuart, known as Blue. Neighborhood names, pub nicknames, on the bodies of men who were about to do something the manual said was impossible. And among the troops, a 24-year-old private named Bruce Kingsbury.
Born in Melbourne, Syria veteran. He’d enlisted in 1940. At 16, he’d had to lie about his age. His name appears in the AWM archives with a note in the margin that says, simply, Victoria Cross. What he did to earn it happens on the third day of the Battle of Isurava. And when we get there, you’ll understand why a Japanese general had to rewrite his own report.
But before that moment, you need to understand what was coming toward them. Because the Nankai Shitai wasn’t just any army. It was the same force that had swept everything aside from Rabaul to the gates of Port Moresby. And it had never found anything that held out for more than 48 hours. To understand what waited for the 2/14th at Isurava, you need to understand one thing about the Nankai Shitai.
It wasn’t just any army. It was the force Japan had specifically sent to finish the job in the South Pacific. Major General Tomitaro Horii commanded it with one fixed idea in his head. Port Moresby. If Japan took Port Moresby, Australia lost its last foothold in the Pacific. The north of the continent was exposed. And the war in the South Pacific ended in a way that Washington and Canberra didn’t want to calculate.
Horii knew it, and he’d been moving as if time was the only enemy that really worried him. In July 1942, the Nankai Shitai landed at Buna with 6,000 soldiers. The 144th Infantry Regiment, elements of the 41st Regiment, the Yokoyama Battalion, engineers, light artillery, signals. 6,000 trained, disciplined men with orders to reach Port Moresby before Australia could reinforce the position.
But here’s the butt. The Kokoda Track was doing to them what it was doing to the Australians. It was destroying them. The Japanese canvas sandals designed for Asian terrain were falling apart in the volcanic mud of the Owen Stanley Mountains. The rice and dried fish rations each soldier carried in his pack ran out within days.
The native carriers who were supposed to maintain the supply line from Buna were starting to disappear. By the time the Nankai Shitai reached Isurava in August, the 6,000 soldiers of the beginning had become something very different. 2,500, maybe 3,000 for the main assault. Chronically hungry, without medicine, with dysentery and malaria in proportions that would have paralyzed any Western army, with ammunition enough for a few days of intense combat, no more.
But they were still lethal. Horii had a doctrine that had worked in every theater of operations across the Pacific. Simple, brutal, effective. First, rapid advance, constant pressure before the enemy could receive reinforcements. The Australians were few. If they were hit with enough speed and enough force, they’d collapse before anyone came to help them.
Second, infiltration and envelopment. Don’t attack frontally when you can surround. Penetrate the flanks, cut the withdrawal routes, infiltrate small forces behind Australian positions to sow panic. Make the enemy feel that danger was coming from every direction simultaneously. Third, night attacks. In the total darkness of the jungle, the defender’s advantage disappears.
No clear fields of fire, no visibility, just the sound of something approaching through the vegetation, and the certainty that there are more of them than you can count. This doctrine had destroyed the American army at Bataan. It had swept the British aside at Singapore. It had crushed the Dutch forces in the East Indies. In every case, the sequence had been the same.
Pressure, infiltration, panic, collapse. Horii had no reason to think Isurava would be different. Tomitaro Horii was 53 years old in August 1942. Disciplined, pragmatic, extraordinarily aggressive as a commander. He’d spent decades in the Imperial Japanese Army learning one lesson that the Pacific campaign had confirmed again and again.
Speed kills the enemy before the enemy can organize. When his scouts reported what they’d find at Isurava, Horii made the calculation any competent commander would have made. Australians, few, exhausted, without adequate supplies, in defensive positions that the terrain made difficult to hold for more than 48 hours. The 39th Battalion, the militia unit that had been holding out in the track for weeks before the 2/14th arrived, was, in theory, what stood between the Nankai Shitai and Port Moresby.
Young, poorly equipped, without real combat experience. Horii had been pushing them for weeks, closer and closer to collapse, further and further south. And then the second 14th arrived to reinforce the position. Horie received the report. Syria veterans, AIF unit, better trained than the militia he’d been crushing.
His response was to increase the pressure because the doctrine said pressure worked, always. But there was something in Horie’s calculation that didn’t add up. It wasn’t an intelligence error. It wasn’t a tactical error. It was something more fundamental. His doctrine was built on a premise the Pacific had confirmed in every previous theater.
That when the pressure is enough, the enemy gives way. What Horie didn’t know, what no intelligence report could have told him, was that the men of the second 14th weren’t evaluating whether they could hold out. They’d already made that decision before they arrived. The Nankai Shitai’s logistics were disintegrating by the day. Ammunition was running out.
Supplies from Buna were arriving in ever smaller quantities. His own men were fighting with hunger and fever. Horie needed Ioribaiwa to fall fast. If it didn’t fall within days, the entire offensive would start to [music] unravel. On the 26th of August, 1942, the Nankai Shitai arrived at Ioribaiwa. 2,500 Japanese soldiers against 450 Australians in a village in the mountains of Papua New Guinea.
The numbers said one thing. What happened over the next four days said something else entirely. And it started that same night. The 26th of August, 1942, dawn. Patrols from the 144th Japanese Regiment started probing the Australian positions before there was enough light to see 10 m. It wasn’t the main assault.
It was the test. The way the Nankai Shitai measured the enemy before committing its full weight. What they found wasn’t what they expected. At midday, C Company of the second 14th relieved a company of the 39th Battalion that had been in position for weeks without real rest. The men of the 39th came out of their weapon pits crying.
Not from relief. From exhaustion. Many couldn’t stand without leaning on something. They’d been fighting with dysentery, without enough food, without enough ammunition, without sleep. And they’d held. A soldier of the 39th wrote in his diary that day something the AWM archives preserve with the precision of a man who no longer has the energy to exaggerate.
“Can’t feel my legs anymore. When they pull back, I think we’ve won. And then they come again.” That afternoon, the Japanese launched three frontal attacks against the new line. The Australians repelled all three. But the ammunition they’d used to repel them wasn’t going to be replaced that night [music] or the next.
The 27th of August, Horie intensified the effort. Coordinated attacks from the front and the right flank simultaneously. Japanese doctrine in its purest form, pressure from multiple directions at the same time so the defender never knew where to concentrate reserves. Because the problem was that the second 14th had no reserves.
The companies of the 39th and the second 14th started mixing together in the fighting. Not from disorganization, from necessity. The Australian flanks were beginning to bend under the pressure, and Lieutenant Colonel Honner was relocating entire sections to plug the gaps that the Japanese pressure was opening in the line.
No clean lines, no defined sectors. Just men in weapon pits that had become mud ditches under the rain that fell without stopping. Firing at silhouettes appearing through the vegetation 10 m away. That night, with mud to their knees and the wounded with no chance of evacuation, a soldier of the second 14th wrote in his diary the line that Kokoda historians have quoted more than any other.
“We weren’t fighting for ground. We were fighting so the bloke next to us didn’t die.” The 28th of August. The third day changed the geometry of the battle. Horie’s forces had taken the heights on both sides of the valley during the night. That meant one thing only. The Japanese could now look directly down onto the Australian positions.
Every movement, every weapon pit, every weak point in the line, C Company of the second 14th absorbed the impact of what came next. Repeated attacks from the front while fire from the heights pinned the defenders in their positions. The 39th, which by then had ammunition for isolated shots and little more, was holding on with grenades and bayonets.
By mid-afternoon, the Japanese broke through at a weak point in the line. Hand-to-hand combat at 10 m, at 15 m, in some places less. Australian counterattacks slowed the advance, but every counterattack cost men who couldn’t be replaced and ammunition that couldn’t be resupplied. Horie looked at the map that night and saw what the numbers were telling him.
Tomorrow, the 29th of August, Horie launched the general assault. Not the probing of the first days, not the gradual pressure of the second and third. The full weight of what remained of the Nankai Shitai concentrated against an Australian line that had spent three days absorbing blows without breaking. C Company of the second 14th gave way.
Not because its men stopped fighting, but because the mathematics Horie had been calculating since the beginning finally prevailed. Too many Japanese, too few Australians. Too much ammunition spent in three days of combat without resupply. The Japanese penetrated the line and started enveloping the Australian positions from within.
In that moment, with the line broken, with the Japanese inside the perimeter, with the second 14th in danger of total collapse, a 24-year-old private made a decision no military manual would have prescribed. Bruce Kingsbury picked up a Bren gun alone, without anyone ordering him to, without waiting for any officer to assess the situation.
He ran down a narrow track under direct Japanese fire toward the point where the line had given way. The survivors who witnessed it described it in AWM archives with words that appear in every single testimony. “He looked like he couldn’t be killed. He moved as if the rain and the bullets didn’t exist.
” Kingsbury’s Bren gun destroyed an entire Japanese assault group. His attack stopped the breakthrough. It bought the second 14th the time it needed to reorganize the line. And then a Japanese sniper found him. Bruce Kingsbury died on that track at 24 years of age with the Bren gun still in his hands. He would receive the Victoria Cross posthumously.
The first Victoria Cross awarded on Australian territory because Papua New Guinea was then Australian territory of the entire Second World War. But in that moment, on that track, what mattered wasn’t any medal. It was that the line had held a little longer. But a little longer wasn’t enough. With C Company destroyed, with the Japanese on the heights on both sides, with hours of ammunition left and not days, Honner made the only decision he could make.
Ordered withdrawal toward Eora Creek. Ordered doesn’t mean without cost. The seriously wounded who couldn’t move under their own power were left behind. Japanese patrols found them. There were no prisoners. 132 Australians killed in four days, 247 wounded, dozens missing whom AWM archives classify with a euphemism that fools nobody.
The 39th and the second 14th came out of Ioribaiwa with less than half their effective strength. They had lost the position. But here’s what the numbers don’t tell. When Horie wrote his report to Rabaul that night, he had to explain something his doctrine had no answer for. Four days. 450 Australians had cost him four days.
And those four days were going to cost him the entire campaign. But that part of the story, what Horie told Rabaul and what Rabaul told him back, that’s what comes next. There’s a way generals lie without knowing they’re lying. It’s not dishonesty, it’s doctrine. When the Nankai Shitai’s doctrine said a line that falls back is a line that has collapsed, Horie wasn’t interpreting the data.
He was applying the only framework he knew. And the framework told him the Australians were destroyed. Three times. The first report reached Rabaul around the 25th of August. “The enemy is exhausted and appears incapable of continuing to fight.” Rabaul logged it, believed it, and pressed Horie to accelerate the advance. The second report arrived on the 27th or 28th of August in the heart of the battle.
“Australian resistance is fragmentary. The main defensive line appears to have collapsed.” Rabaul believed it again. Internal communications of the 17th Army assumed the Australian withdrawal would be permanent, that the resistance was low quality, that Port Moresby was days away. But, here’s the butt. While Horii was sending that second report, the second, 14th, and the 39th were still in their weapon pits.
Still firing. Still counter-attacking. Still alive. The third report arrived on the morning of the 29th of August. We judge that the enemy has been annihilated. That same morning, Bruce Kingsbury was picking up a Bren gun and running toward the Japanese down a narrow track under direct fire. In Rabaul, the Japanese high command had a picture of the Australians built on what they’d seen in the first months of the Pacific.
Local militia. Irregulars, without capacity for prolonged combat in the jungle. It was a reasonable assessment based on available evidence. The first contacts on the track had been with the 39th Battalion young men, poorly equipped, without real combat experience. But there was something Rabaul didn’t know. The second, 14th, wasn’t militia.
They were Syria veterans, men who had fought against Vichy French troops in one of the most forgotten theaters of the war. Men who knew exactly what sound a bullet makes when it passes too close. Men who had learned in the Syrian desert something that appears in no combat manual. That fear doesn’t disappear.
But you can keep functioning with it. Rabaul kept pressing. Accelerate the advance. Exploit the enemy collapse. Don’t stop to consolidate. Horii kept advancing. And on the front line, his own soldiers were writing things very different from what the official reports said. The personal diaries of soldiers from the 144th Regiment tell a completely different story to Horii’s reports.
Not the story of a destroyed enemy. The story of an enemy that wouldn’t quit. One soldier wrote about Australian marksmanship with a precision that only comes from someone who’s been on the receiving end of it. The Australian soldiers have accurate shooting. We cannot let our guard down. Another noted something simpler, harder to ignore.
Even being few, they defend their positions well. But the most revealing thing wasn’t what they wrote about the Australians. It was what they wrote about themselves. More fearsome than the enemy are the mountain and the disease. There are no supplies. Even if we win, we will die. The supply line from Buna was disintegrating.
The native carriers had fled. The rice and dried fish rations each soldier carried in his pack had run out days ago. The men attacking the Australian positions at Isurava were doing so chronically hungry, with dysentery, with canvas sandals destroyed [music] by volcanic mud. And still they attacked. Because the doctrine said the enemy was destroyed.
Because Horii had said the enemy was destroyed. Because Rabaul expected the enemy to be destroyed. And somewhere between the second and third report, someone on the front line wrote in his diary the sentence that Kokoda historians have cited more than any other from the Japanese archives. The Australians do not break easily.
Five words in the diary of a soldier who expected them to break within 48 hours. Horii took Isurava on the 29th of August. Tactically, it was a victory. The Australians had withdrawn. The road to Port Moresby was open. But here’s what the reports to Rabaul didn’t say. Four days. The second, 14th, and the 39th had cost the Nankai Shitai four days that were in no campaign plan.
Four days of ammunition consumed that couldn’t be replaced. Four days of men killed that couldn’t be replaced. Four days that Australia used to move reinforcements toward Port Moresby. The 21st Brigade. The 25th Brigade. Fresh units, well-equipped, taking positions at the points Horii needed to take before they arrived.
The window the Nankai Shitai needed to reach Port Moresby before Australia could reinforce the position had closed. Not dramatically. Not with a decisive battle. With four days of exhausted men in mud weapon pits who refused to give way any faster than they gave way. And while those Australian reinforcements were arriving, the Nankai Shitai kept advancing south with less ammunition, less food, and fewer men than the day before.
Japan’s fastest offensive in the South Pacific had become a war of attrition. And a war of attrition was exactly the kind of war Japan couldn’t win in that terrain. In September 1942, Tokyo ordered the withdrawal. Not because the Australians had won a decisive open battle, but because the relentless logic of the Kokoda track had done what 450 Australians at Isurava had started.
It had destroyed the Nankai Shitai’s logistics from within. Horii began pulling back toward Buna, the same route he’d advanced with 6,000 soldiers in July. Now he was retreating with a fraction of that force, hungry, sick, pursued by the same Australians he’d reported as destroyed 3 months earlier. November 1942, the Kumusi River.
Horii was trying to cross by boat. The river was in flood. The waters raging. The boat capsized. Tomitaro Horii was swept away by the current of the same river his army had crossed in triumph months before. His body was never recovered. The commander of the offensive that was going to end the war in the South Pacific drowned in a river in Papua New Guinea.
Not in combat. Not in a final battle. Defeated by the same terrain he’d underestimated from the beginning. The men of the second, 14th who came out of Isurava didn’t rest. They couldn’t. The Japanese were still advancing. And the track was still the only place they could be stopped. The second, 14th kept fighting at Eora Creek, at Templeton’s Crossing, at Efogi.
Each position a repetition of Isurava. Fewer men, less ammunition, less food against a force that was still numerically superior, though each day more desperate. The battalion was reconstituted. It went back to the front. It fought in New Guinea. It fought in Borneo. Many of the men who survived Isurava never talked too much about what happened there.
Their diaries do. The AWM archives preserve them. And today, they are among the most cited testimonies of the entire Kokoda campaign. Not because they’re written with eloquence. But because they’re written with the honesty of men who knew exactly what each line had cost them. In 2002, Australia inaugurated the Isurava Memorial on the exact same ground where the second, 14th, and the 39th had dug their weapon pits 60 years before.
Four stones. Four words. Courage. Endurance. Mateship. Sacrifice. Every year, thousands of Australians walk the Kokoda track. 96 kilometers of mud, rain, and vegetation that their grandfathers and great-grandfathers had covered with rifles and not enough food. When they reach Isurava, many stop longer than necessary.
Not because the memorial is especially large. But because four words in stone say what no history book has managed to say with the same economy. In Australian military history, Isurava occupies the same space as Gallipoli. The same reverent tone. The same sense that what happened there says something about who Australians are that no clean victory could ever say.
Because Isurava wasn’t a clean victory. It was four days of exhausted, sick men with ammunition running low who decided that falling back any faster wasn’t an option. Bruce Kingsbury received the Victoria Cross posthumously, the first awarded on Australian territory of the entire Second World War. He was 24 years old.
He’d lied about his age to enlist. [music] And he died on a narrow track in a Papua New Guinea jungle doing what the AWM archives describe simply as a voluntary counter-attack. As if that said everything. And perhaps it does. There’s something about this story that official reports never capture. Not the numbers. Not the casualties.
Not the strategic victory that the sacrifice at Isurava made possible. It’s this. Horii reported three times that the Australians were destroyed. Three times they kept fighting. And in the diaries of the Japanese soldiers who were watching it from the other side, men who expected them to surrender within 48 hours, there is the only honest assessment of what happened at Isurava.
The Australians do not break easily. No Australian officer wrote that. No historian wrote it. It was written by someone on the other side trying to break them. And he couldn’t. There’s another story just as buried as this one. A group of Australians who were also written off as finished before the battle was over.
In a completely different theater. With an outcome that changed something far bigger than a single campaign. It’s in the next video.